Walking Tour: Chicago Theatre/1833 Treaty Negotiations

The Chicago Theatre is a historic building, and its large marquee has become an icon of Chicago. However, the theater also sits on the site of one of the camps that Neshnabé (Potawatomi, Ojibwe, and Odawa) people created during the negotiations of the 1833 Treaty of Chicago. That year, Neshnabé representatives were called to Chicago to negotiate additional land cessions in the Midwest. They built massive encampments around Fort Dearborn and lived there the month before finally meeting with US Commissioners on September 21 for negotiations across the river from the fort.

In the 18th and 19th centuries, land cessions from Indigenous nations were made through treaties (legal agreements) with the U.S. federal government. These treaties were often negotiated at established meeting places like Chicago and are not necessarily named for the land that is being ceded. Such is the case for the 1833 Treaty of Chicago which ceded land tracts in northern Illinois and southern Wisconsin and orchestrated the forced removal of Neshnabé people from 8 million acres of land in what are now the states of Illinois, Indiana, and Michigan.

The treaty was signed on September 26, and it began another migration into the city. Knowing that Neshnabé leaders would soon be receiving their treaty payments, hundreds of American traders from the midwest descended on the city to collect on supposed debts they claimed from Native people. These creditors made up $175,000 of the annuities listed in the treaty, equivalent to about $6.5 million dollars in 2024. In the cash-poor economy of the Midwest, these payments were a massive influx of federal dollars into the region.

Over the next decade, Neshnabé people were removed from the 8 million acres of land in Illinois, Indiana, and Michigan in a fragmented and abusive way over the course of nearly a dozen different removals. At least 5 of these removals began at or crossed through the Chicagoland area.

Proceed north, turning right on Lake Street for one block, then turning left onto Wabash and proceeding north one block. When you reach East Wacker, turn right, and make your way back to the southwest corner of DuSable bridge for the final stop on this walking tour (.4 miles).

Sources:

John P. Bowes, Land Too Good for Indians: Northern Indian Removal, (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2016).
Frances L. Hagemann, A History of American Indians of the Chicago Metropolitan Region and the Western Great Lakes (Hometown, IL: Floating Feather Press of History Research Enterprises, 2004).
Charles Joseph Kappler, Indian Treaties, 1778-1883 (New York: Interland Publishing, 1972), http://archive.org/details/indiantreaties170000kapp. Charles Joseph Latrobe, The Rambler in North America, 1832-1833 (New York, Harper and Brothers, 1835).
Twenty-Second Congress of The United States, “An Act to Enable the President to Extinguish Indian Title within the State of Indiana, Illinois, and Territory of Michigan.,” Pub. L. No. CLXXV, 564 (1832)